Dissection Alternatives Essay - 2540 Words

Dissection Alternatives Dissection in science classrooms is an experience that almost every student has to go through, but one that many will regret. It is estimated that six million vertebrate animals are dissected in high schools each year, and another 5.7 million are used in college laboratories. The issue of educational dissection has become a national concern. Many groups such as PETA and The Humane Society have been lobbying for years to outlaw such practices, and implement new and safe dissection alternatives. Alternatives to dissection have become more popular in recent decades and may be the future of modern science and education. A dissection alternative is defined as an educational aid or teaching approach that replaces†¦show more content†¦They ruled that under her First Amendment rights Jennifer could object to the dissection on moral grounds, and therefore could not be forced to participate. Jennifer’s high school then instated a student choice policy so that students who chose not to participate in dissections would be offered a viable alternative. Now there are seven states that have informed consent laws regarding classroom dissection: Florida, California, Maine, Pennsylvania, Louisiana, Rhode Island, and New York. These laws require that students must be informed of a dissection lab at the beginning of a course, and if they wish, will be provided with an alternative. There are also two states where it is mandatory that students are provided with dissection alternatives: Maryland, and Illinois. There are also several nations that have banned educational dissection from their science curriculums. Argentina was the first in 1987, followed by Slovakia (1994), and Israel (1999). And in 2001, India banned the use of mice, rats, and frogs for any type of dissection purposes. The main issue with statewide dissection laws is that they only apply to elementary, middle, and high schools. Colleges and Universities are not required to follow each state’s policy. This can create many problems. At one particular University, the student choice policy for dissection may very from department to department or even from teacher to teacher. This can be very confusing andShow MoreRelatedBenefits of Dissection818 Words   |  3 Pages Dissection, by definition, is the pathological splitting or separation of tissue, according to Webster’s online dictionary. Beneath the simple definition lies an immense amount of controversy. This paper will provide pros and cons regarding ethics of dissection. Dissection has many benefits. The experience of dissection is unforgettable. â€Å"Things you can actually touch usually stick in your head better,† according to Dr. Damon Scoville. Dissection is an approach to science that creates a lastingRead MoreThe Clay Learning System-Maniken in My Anatomy and Phisiology Class971 Words   |  4 Pagesopportunity in preparing of those goals. Clay modeling is an appropriate alternative to animal dissection for my students as it employs cooperative learning opportunities and a kinesthetic approach that is essential for their learning. The Anatomy in Clay has the potential to be used for almost every body system covered in Human Anatomy and Physiology. x The human Maniken clay-sculpting experience may be more effective than an animal dissection because the human-clay sculpting experience will engage the studentsRead MoreAnimal Testing And Its Effects On The Poor Treatment Of Animals1093 Words   |  5 Pagesanimal. Often animals may even be killed during or at the end of an experiment, but occasionally some may be used again in another test. Cosmetic testing prepares for human use and the products safety. In some cases, after considering accessible alternatives, companies may find that animal testing is necessary to verify the safety of a product. Animals are tested on skin creams, perfumes, lipsticks, nail polishes, eye and facial makeup, shampoos, and hair color for companies seeking to market new productsRead MoreIs the Killing of Animals for Research Okay? Essay1459 Words   |  6 Pagestrials are conducted on humans. Tests on animals are done to establish safety levels for humans of known toxic substances (1:40). nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Although testing might seem like the most efficient way to gain knowledge in these areas, alternatives exist. The use of slides, films, computer programs, and models can fulfill the same job without any harm. For example, in vet schools the symptoms of strychnine poisoning were demonstrated by poisoning dogs and then put on a video tape. On theRead MoreEssay about Animal Testing Should Be Outlawed1110 Words   |  5 Pagesefficacy of test drugs before proceeding to human clinical trials. Animal experimentation has been going on since ancient Greece when Aristotle and Hippocrates first made their model of the human body based on what they had observed through animal dissection. Then, Romans used animals to do more psychological tests on animals like pigs, monkeys and dogs. After that, the Renaissance period took up physiological studies. Since then, the 20th century had a huge increase in animal testing until 1980 whenRead MoreEssay on Animal Rights1331 Words   |  6 Pagesanimals in scientific experimentation. In today’s society groups such as People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) have continued these traditional fights as well as adding new agendas. These new agendas include hunting and fishing, and dissection of animals in science classes. This paper will discuss the pros and cons of animal experimentation and research, animals in the classroom, animal organizations and hunting. Along with these topics my personal opinion will be stated, before and afterRead MoreAnimal Rights : Animal Or Its Organs And Tissues Are Used1335 Words   |  6 Pagesanother drawback (Balls, 1994). 2. Three Rs: reduction, refinement and replacement Alternatives to animal testing were proposed to overcome some of the drawbacks associated with animal experiments and avoid the unethical procedures. A strategy of 3 Rs is being applied which stands for reduction, refinement and replace- ment of laboratory use of animals (Ranganatha and Kuppast, 2012). Different methods and alternative organisms are ap- plied to implement this strategy. The concept of replacement ofRead MoreAnimal Experimentation And Its Effects On Human Life And Survival965 Words   |  4 Pagesadvantageous information. Animal experimentation is extremely criticized by the animal rights activists. They believe that deaths through research are considered unnecessary â€Å"Animals have right to live their own life peacefully† (David M. Haugen). Animal dissection is regarded as misleading. Thus, the critics of animal experimentation argue that the cruel animal experimentation is morally not different from murder. The arguments for and against animal experimentation are going to continue for some time. BeingRead MoreAnimal Testing And Its Impact On The Environment2372 Words   |  10 Pageseven humans. The notion of animals being able to serve as a model for humans was supported by Charles Darwin’s evolutionary theory in 1859 (Hawkins). Even prior to this theory, however, surgery on animals became popular in ancient Greece due to the dissection of human beings being considered as taboo (Franco). English physician William Harvey (1578-1657) disproved the common belief at the time that the lungs circulated blood throughout the body through his experience in animal experimentation (Ribatti)Read More Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Essay1487 Words   |  6 Pagesis recommended for aneurysms larger than 5 cm in diameter based on clinical studies in indicating that the risk of rupture within a five year period is 25% to 41%. There is also a high likelihood of limb loss from peripheral embolizati on. An alternative to surgical repair is endovascular aneurysm repair (Stoelting 143). It is important preoperatively to identify co-existing medical conditions. Two 14 gauge intravenous catheters should also be placed preoperatively. Coronary artery disease, hypertension